Take Care of Us, Captaion

Ku Hye Sun and Plot the Reasons for ‘Captain’ Failure

With overly exaggerated setting and criticism on Ku Hye Sun’s acting, Take Care of Us, Captain is been deserted by viewers.

The rating for episode 8 of SBS Wednesday and Thursday drama series broadcast on January 26th, 2012 is 8.5% (national average based on AGN Nielson Media Research), showing an obvious decline. But The Moon Embracing the Sun broadcast at the same time rose 1.4% over last episode to get rating of 31.7%.

The initial acting of Ku Hye Sun and unreasonable setting drive the development of plot, but still does not solve the problems.

In particular, beginning from episode 5, with the addition of new scriptwriter, the plot starts to increasingly tension, and the initial questions solved, but it continues to be confined by stimulating theme, resulting in “conventional drama” comment.

The most important plot of the drama is the growth story of passionate female pilot, but unlike with original production intent, in every episode is far-fetched setting and Ku Hye Sun’s acting which does not improve.

Take Care of Us, Captaion

The censure on Ku Hye Sun’s acting which was raised on first episode does not die out even until episode 8.

It’s about acting of Ku Hye Sun which has not much different in expressions with her previous appearance in drama King and I and Boys Over Flowers. If there is no control in expressions, the acting is as stiff as a poker and not harmonious with co-starring actors, hinder the immersion into the plot.

Coupled with the co-pilot does not want to quit, and cannot control own emotions, showing the non-professionalism, reducing the realism of the role itself, triggering controversy.

The addition of new scriptwriter on the one hand input the element of professionalism, reducing the dramatic elements, one the one hand emphasis on setting of each episode, on another hand hinder the dramatic focus.

The most important thing is that the broadcast of episode 8 on January 26, 2012 contains stimulating act of indecent sexual act towards the crews, and the behavior of the shirts of passenger and steward were torn. These situations reduced the will of viewers to watch the drama, and rally the viewers to attack the drama.

Through the drama’s message board, audience commented, “The drama is too much,” “Anticipation of Ji Jin Hee’s starring, but burdened by Ku Hye Sun,” “Acting which is not harmonized,” “After change of scriptwriter the plot becomes abnormal?” “The story plot gradually deviates,” “it’s full of far-fetched setting,” “conventional style drama,” “is this a drama airline crews want?” “This is not practical” and so on.

Finally, with the unfolding of the story, the controversy on acting of main actors, the own problem is exposed, and the ratings are even lower.

In this regard, the directors of Take Care of Us, Captain, Joo Dong-min, was explaining about the problem of story development and actors’ acting, “There are two scriptwriters for the drama, but to immediately incur change is difficult. From episode 7 onwards will give a lot more care. If there is any weaknesses, will make improvement in future, so stay tuned.”

via Nate


Posted

in

by

Comments

33 responses to “Ku Hye Sun and Plot the Reasons for ‘Captain’ Failure”

  1. […] Ku Hye Sun and Plot the Reasons for ‘Captain’ Failure […]

  2. Xeila Avatar
    Xeila

    I don’t believed it’s Hyesun…Koreans just love traditional Saeguk Drama , In fairness to Hyesun her acting in this drama improve a lot . Let the SBS change the timing or air it earlier than TMES , and KOREANS surely will watch it….

  3. Dahlia Avatar

    I love this drama its not Ku Hye Sun its TMES because koreans just love their Saeguk Drama I agree with Xeila :)

  4. Tambuts Avatar
    Tambuts

    This article is over exaggerated and critizing alone GHS acting for the low ratings; if you are watching Korean Drama you must know that Koreans into Saeguk Drama..this article is obviously bias to GHS…

  5. Teresita Avatar

    this is not really fair for GHS..are they really watching PCAP..GHS is a natural actress..i can see how much SADNESS GHS is experiencing again working so hard for PCAP and people blaming her if they are not watching it PLEASE IF YOU ARE NOT WATCHING IT I DON’T THINK YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO JUDGE HER..THANKS GOD HER FAMILY IS ALWAYS WITH HER.. 

  6. zuidai_21 Avatar
    zuidai_21

    this article is really too much. why put the blame to an actress who worked so hard. I’m not an actress but I know how actors and actressess works in order to present the story well. this article is unfair and biased. It really shows that you are not watching each episode and only writing without even making research on it. I followed each episode and I know how koo hye sun work hard on it. Please dont demoralized her because it is very hurtful also on our side who love her.

  7. uno Avatar
    uno

    Of course it is not koo hye sun fault. she improves a lot in her acting. Dont be so unfair. How can you say that youre not even watching the drama. You are only good in creating words but you are not thinking what you are writing.

  8. irishkkh Avatar
    irishkkh

    O my this article is too much. im a silent follower of koo hye sun and im not fond of posting comment, but I cant take this time. This is so unfair. Really this isnt fair. How can you say those words?youre not watching her arent you. I think youre only one of her anti. But you cant put her down. She is a very talented actress. she knows how to handle her emotions, acting and maintains her craft. Goo hye sun be strong and dont mind them God bless you always.

  9.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    From my observation, koreans love to watch dramas with the same theme over and over.  I don’t blame them though maybe because of historical and cultural influences.  For me, Please Captain’s story somehow has a westernized concept and does not adapt to the taste of the usual korean drama formulas such as romance-comedy and saeguk.  I may agree with some of what is written above but it is important to note that it is unfair to blame it mostly to Koo Hye Sun.  There are many factors to be considered why the drama is not earning higher ratings but it is not Koo Hye Sun’s fault alone.  It is precisely why it is called a drama.  Otherwise, Koo Hye Sun would have made a monologue.  This said, I hope people does not give Koo Hye Sun a hard time.  There are lots of actresses who do not know how to act at all (including the facial expression which the author of the above article has mentioned), but somehow they were left unnoticed and not given treatment as some sites or news deal with Koo Hye Sun.  While Koo should be honored because of the attention that the public is giving her, I am saddened, however, by the negative comments which she has consistently been getting.  I noticed though that most articles contain negative comments.  But when Koo Hye Sun does good things, they do not publicize the same.  She has done lots in this drama. She even sung one song for its ost, however, this again was left unnoticed.  I enjoy Please Captain more than TMETS.  Maybe it’s a matter of preference.  Maybe the author of this article is more interested with the plot of TMETS which, for me, is similar with other saeguk dramas. Or maybe he/she does not like Koo Hye Sun at all.         

  10.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    I would like to believe that Goo Hye Sun is such a big celebrity in Korea that she is perceived as the sole flag bearer of this drama, Take Care of us Captain, but singling her out among the actors as the main cause of the drama’s decline is really UNFAIR.  It is such a harsh reality that this drama is not as popular as those which debuted with TCOUC at the same time but in my opinion the reason is more on viewers not so keen on the theme of the drama rather than GHS’s acting.  I am enjoying watching the drama and hoping that the storyline gets more interesting in the subsequent episodes.  It is just tough luck I guess that most viewers prefer a SAGEUK-themed drama to watch, thus Captain’s rating is really affected.  However, knowing how GHS takes things in stride, she will rise above this just like any past constructive criticisms thrown her lap.  Go, fight, win GHS, continue doing stuff which you are passionate about!

  11. Jerq Avatar
    Jerq

    It’s so sadden that many articles is so written with the bad criticism about GHS , but then the positive aspects about her is set aside.Like for example the new OST that she has written and even sang for the PCAP , it was beautifully done but nobody care to write about it…sigh……..
    About her being the solely bearer of the law rating , It’s UNFAIR to her …It maybe low rating in Korea but internationally PCAP is anticipated Drama many viewers is waiting for every Wed. & Thurs.I don’t  blame Koreans for being traditional because I know how they love saeguk Drama .It’s just so sad that PCAP is same time and day with the TMETS if not ;sure thing it’s different issue…

  12. regie Avatar
    regie

    this article is absurd! why blame it all to GHS? the way i see it, this article is trying to demoralize GHS, her fans and the viewers of PCAP. why are mean articles coming out like mushrooms lately? first, her so-called retirement from acting and now this? can anything like praising her for the OST of PCAP worth writing this time? the songs are awesome and GHS made it happen! c’mon…be fair to GHS! she doesn’t deserve this antagonism. 

  13. Amysupat Avatar
    Amysupat

    I love PCAP, it’s a heartwarming drama and I love GHS acting. Well all I can say criticisms are around, it’s enevitable. Yet criticisms itself can make a person grow and develop or make a person down. But in the case of GHS I’m glad that she takes cristicisms in a lighter,positive way. Thus make her a more mature and sensible person and have positive views in life and at the same time has an childlike manner in her which makes simple and down to earth. A person can never be open and humble if she/he does always get the praises in life. GHS may look fragile but tough inside because she knows she can never please everyone else and nobody would appreciate she is except herself and family alone. 

  14. Yanna Ingkoh Ü Avatar

    This article is too much. C’mon guys, acting must receive evaluation from withing the drama. It is not about comparing the acting of one actor with the actor’s previous acting. GHS is really a very great actress. I pity her for so many antis. But, I still admire her. She’s my favorite actress. And I’m loving Please Take Care of us, Captain!

  15. Shehe Avatar
    Shehe

    Whoever wrote this article don’t know squat about what they’re talking about.  In the first place, before you even start criticizing, make sure you’ve watched the drama in it’s entirety, otherwise it’s just your way of putting down GHS.  

    It’s dumb to blame an actor for the low ratings of a drama.  An actor just interprets what’s written in the script.  I don’t understand what type of acting you expect from GHS because the story is pretty much straightforward.  Your criticism of GHS’s acting is so general that I’m of the opinion that you never even looked at her acting closely.  BOF and PCAP are two different dramas but the emotions conveyed like sorrow, joy, anger are pretty basic.  And GHS did give credence to Jandi and Han Da Jin.  

    Not only that, she also wrote those beautiful songs with it’s haunting lyrics for PCAP.  Now, why, I’m wondering, are you not talking about that.  

    The ratings of Korean dramas are not a good indicator of whether the drama is good or not.  In the first place, Koreans love their saeguk dramas but these dramas will not fare good ratings internationally.  In other words, the ratings are based on local viewership but internationally, The Musical and Please Captain have wider international audience.  It’s just unfortunate that  international viewers are not included in the survey.

    It riles me when writers like you come out of the woodwork and thinks good journalism is cutting a person down with blatantly biased, unfair comments and whose prose is malicious at best.

  16. Jolie Avatar
    Jolie

    It’s not fair if you blame on someone for the low ratings. If it’s something, I can only say that you’re very prejudice, and not give a balance information. Your article is not worth reading. Im sure you write here because no other place that can accept your low opinion. 

  17. Sukreena Om Avatar

    I can’t believe this!!! I think this is the worst article i’ve read critised an actress who is multi-talented. You can’t blame GHS for low rating is such a bias and prejudice on her part. Why compare Geum Jandi and Han Dajin, both entirely are different characters, the only similarity is, both are cheerful and hardworking.

    If you said GHS acting is not good than there are others actresses who are far far worst than her. She’s one in a
    million who has natural beauty with gifted talented, brainy, cheerful,
    hardworking and she’s humble too where it’s hard to find in other
    actresses. This citeria makes her a special person.

    I’m wondering why you don’t acknowledged the good things GHS did for PCAP?

    The Asiana Air feels that Ku Hye
    Sun fits the image of “beautiful people” very well. They want to provide
    all that is needed for the drama. The production team is very happy
    that they are able to make a drama as true to reality as possible
    thanks to Ku Hye Sun with the ”pretty smile”. Instead of a made up set,
    the drama will be filmed using the real training facility, study area
    and more. Many details and aspects never shown to the public about the
    airport and airline will be broadcast through the drama.

    Another thing that she also wrote those beautiful songs with it’s haunting
    lyrics for PCAP.  Now, this also you not talking about it.

    Don’t you think this is a good business strategies she did for PCAP?
     
    Judging by this article look like Koreans still can’t accept modern drama like PCAP, especially where woman involved in a man career field but don’t bias on a GHS.
     

  18. IHeartThePrincess Avatar
    IHeartThePrincess

    Korean viewers will always be obsessed with Saeguk dramas, they love to watch princesses, prince, kings, wars over and over again, no matter how ordinary and usual the story is…PCAP is an INNOVATION. A first in Korean drama, unusual, brave and intelligent way to make an elegant difference in Korean drama. GOO HYE SUN’s acting in PCAP is EXCELLENT, PERIOD! Her eyes communicate with the audience well, even without lines, she can make you cry, smile and laugh, effortlessly. GOO HYE SUN is one of the very few korean actresses who ACT NATURALLY. She knows when to shout, to increase her voice, to remain silent, she even knows how to make her tears, in such a perfect timing, and this is seldom among actors. I work in an airline company for almost 9 years now, and I CAN ASSURE YOU THAT PCAP SITUATIONS, LINES ARE NOTHING, BUT REALITY. The writers did their research well. PCAP is an intelligent drama. It doesn’t insult audience’ intelligence, like the other dramas I watched (being a movie and tv critic myself). Its like a tv series made from hollywood which obviously does not appeal to Korean public. There are a lot of korean actors/actresses who do the ‘over acting facial expressions’ over and over again, but not GHS. Some actresses even have voice that can make you want to turn off the tv, a source of noise pollution I should say.

    For those who always criticize GOO HYE SUN’s acting have nothing but insecurities in their life. Who wants to be like her, but ELEGANCE can’t be teach. It’s either you have it you don’t. and GOO HYE SUN is an ELEGANT WOMAN, period. No matter how you put her down, she will always remain as elegant as always. 

    This article is unfair, unjust, and totally BASELESS. i SUGGEST THAT YOU WATCH FIRST BEFORE MAKING ANY NON SENSE WRITE-UPS.

    PCAP may not receive very high rating in Korea, but its receiving so much love all over the world, those who are METICULOUS, INTELLIGENT and TIRED OF THE USUAL KOREAN DRAMAS.

    1. Jasmin Figueras Espeña Avatar

      very well said…i love goo hye sun so much…her acting really amazed me..my mom and i watching this drama because of her, she really makes us laugh or cry…i don’t know why there is this kind of write-ups about her, that was so unfair to her…. 

  19. Sukreena Om Avatar

    What another critics? This is absurd and unfair on GHS part.

    Nothing better to write, to compared Geum Jandi and Han Dajin? This was
    entirely 2 different stories and characters. Why not ask yourself, if
    you’re acting what is your guideline, script right? So we act according to
    what had been written on the script and instructed by the directors
    right, so same applies to GHS, so how can you say her acting the same?

    Why people like to talk about negative things, why no one mentioned the good deeds that GHS had done for PCAP?

    1) She also wrote those beautiful songs and sang for OST PCAP.

    2) Another big helping hand rendered by GHS as per cut nate news below dated 17-11-2011 (refer to : nate.news/view20111171n07017)

    The
    Asiana Air feels that Ku Hye Sun fits the image of “beautiful people”
    very well. They want to provide all that is needed for the drama.

    Ku Hye Sun who will play Han
    DaJin will receive all the clothes and equipment related to flying
    through the support of Asiana Air. Even
    at the location filming of the drama in Australia, Ku Hye Sun rode in
    the Asiana’s airplane and was able to get a tour of the all the places
    that are normally prohibited to the regular passengers. It was a
    meaningful experience for Ku Hye Sun. From now on, she will also receive
    pilot study and training from the Asiana Air as well.

    The
    production team is very happy that they are able to make a drama as
    true to reality as possible thanks to Ku Hye Sun with the ”pretty
    smile”. Instead of a made up set, the drama will be filmed using the
    real training facility, study area and more. Many details and aspects
    never shown to the public about the airport and airline will be
    broadcast through the drama.

    This 2 items are not small matters in the eyes of business, it means strategies, satisfaction, sucess and profits.

    From what the journalist wrote here it look like Koreans still cannot
    accept the moden drama where woman is involved in man’s career field.
    Yet to blame GHS for low rating is unfair, bias and prejudice on her
    part.

    1. nana khair Avatar
      nana khair

       i’m not korean and don’t want to watch this drama any more. Why? becaouse i did’t like her acting!  no other reason! i  like ji jin hee, but thats not enough to make me interesting for watching till end…

      1. Edel_castillo Avatar
        Edel_castillo

         dont watch then ur so mean anyway

  20. cha omz Avatar

    I love this drama no matter what!

    i think this fanpage overthrow PCAP and too adore TMES, sorry too say but I observe it from the news that recently post, too much TMES. #gnashing teeth

  21. cha omz Avatar

    i love PCAP no matter what!

    i think this fanpage overthrow pcap and too adore tmes, sorry to say, but i observe it from the news that recently post, yes, too much TMES! #gnashing teeth

  22. swt Avatar
    swt

    New to Kdrama. No other K actress of particular note to compare GHS with so I’m pretty objective.  She has carried my interest in watching PTCOUC because I dont think I’ve ever seen an instance when her portrayal of the mood, emotion of the moment was out of character.  In fact I see a very sensitive and engaged artist at her best.  

    Which is why the claims ‘no control of emotions’, ‘stiff as poker’, ‘not harmonious with co-starring actors’ has me wondering that this author have some axe to grind for reasons only known to him/her and in the process has completely lost the deal.

    Also blaming her ‘ poor’ acting for the low viewer ratings is carrying one too far.  You mean to say it got so bad that nothing else about the series – unique story line, pretty impressive setting and strong portrayal of the rest of the cast including cute ‘Fluffy’ and the beautiful music can justify spending their time on following the drama?  How absolutely pathetic. 

    The author should get an opinion poll from the international viewing fraternity as to what they think of GHS’s acting ability. I am convinced given your almost unredemptive opinion you will not be pleased with the results.  Korea is turning out gems in the movie & drama industry and this one is no exception thanks in large part to the quality of the show and not very least GHS’s acting and that of the rest of the cast.  You should be justifiably proud of her talent, not tear her down as your article did.

    I watch PTCOUC purely for entertainment as I am sure it is for the larger audience and if this drama has succeeded in serving its purpose, then its kudos to the whole production team and cast, notably the leads.  You have made a kdrama addict outta me :)

    1. nana khair Avatar
      nana khair

      but i realy decided to stop watching this drama cz khs acting! i was realy iritated with her act. force my self to watch the drama till ep 12 was enough, my mood become verry bad for days cz her… i’m seriuos!!!

  23. drmjs Avatar
    drmjs

    I’ve just discovered this site because I’m looking for information on Take Care Of Us, Captain. I’m loving the drama so I’m really surprised at the amount of vitriol being thrown at GHS. It seems ridiculous to lay the blame of ratings decline on a single actor. There are other factors at play and I’m glad that the production team is trying to make the neccessary changes and there is the fact that it’s pitted against a sageuk. We all know how Koreans love their sageuks.

    In fact, IMO, GHS really shines in this drama. The character she portrays is about a young co-pilot who has a hard time coping because she lost her parents earlier on. The lack of a mature, responsible and dominant figure in her life led her to cope with situations as she seems fit. From how I understand it, she has been flying below the radar for quite some time and was getting away with it until the Captain (JJH) came along. Ergo, we see an upstart who is emotional and seeemingly crass. GHS embodied the role perfectly. The plot revolves around her evolution to become a a full fledged captain so we have to see her at this stage and undergo a process of development right?

    As a member of the international community who actually appreciates the drama, I hope that it would get the love it deserves from the viewing public and for it to be able to decently hold it’s own against the sageuk.  

  24. Bfph Avatar
    Bfph

    Big bravo to all who appreciate GHS and the rest of the cast of Take CAre of Us Captain..I really don’t understand why the criticism on a single actor for the success and failure of a drama.Let’s face it a lot of great Korean dramas are underrated while some are overrated.. Take care of us captain is a new innovation, great settings,great cast, superb acting! It get’s me frustrated that they don’t seem to appreciate there Kdramas when I myself not a Korean dp appreciate it very much! Please stop all these negative comments and write ups because it does nothing good. just Love love love and peace! GHS and the rest of Take Care of Us Captain,FIGHTING!!!

    1. nana khair Avatar
      nana khair

       i wil try to make u understand… i’m one of the people wich choose to stop watching this drama. her acting is lack, ji jin hee good acting make her even look more bad…for example, how her walk, thats not a pilot walk! her childish caracter not fit with her burden and her pilot job, her monoton expresion… etc… bored! its look verry strange if JJh going to in love with her caracter… soooo frustrated…. i don’t want to watch this drama any more even my favorit actor JJH there…

      1. MJSMD Avatar
        MJSMD

        You know what it’s your choice if you do not plan on continuing the drama because of your dislike of GHS. But you do not have to go around convincing other people to dislike the drama, especially if they have been vocal about their preference for it and their appreciation for GHS. It’s just not politically correct my dear.

  25. Ezzah Fatin Jemain Avatar

    all I can say is, those who decide to neglect this drama are totally in loss. i think the story line is good, and it makes me go heart thumping and excited for the next episode. I go crazy waiting for the subs and still going crazy watching without subs. Ku Hye Sun changes my POV over pilot since I always thought those with that uniform, flying a plane have a life as perfect as a pro which is totally not the always case. TCOU,C fighting! please make the series longer. I want more and more episodes! 

  26. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    As the saying goes, if you have nothing good to say, then dont comment. Nobody force you to watch. With your negative comments, it hurt other people feelings. There are alays someone you like or you dislike.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share This

Share this post with your friends!